16/09/2017 00:00
Support Catalan independence or not, many of my Spanish friends admire the way in which Britain went about the referendums in Scotland and over Europe. They consider both events clear and strong examples of a true democracy, something, many say, they do not in Spain, especially if you live in Catalonia and want to break away from Spain.
3 comments
To be able to write a comment, you have to be registered and logged in
Richard, you miss the crux of the issue - the 1978 constitution was voted on by a Spanish electorate and Catalonia had no way of opting out of it!
The UK Brexit vote was democratic as all of the UK we're eligible to vote. The vote for Scotland leaving the UK was not democratic because Wales Northern Ireland and England were excluded from the note. The Catalan vote, should it take place will be undemocratic as the majority of Spain is excluded.
Spain has a written constitution, unlike the UK, which does not allow referendums organised by so called autonmous regions. If they want to hold one, then the first thing they should do is to achieve a majority of 2/3 in parliament to change the constitution. That is what is called democracy, as any US citizen would agree.